sb-nz logo
Story image

Why encryption causes DDoS defence headaches

04 Dec 2018

Article by NETSCOUT Arbor Asia Pacific regional director Jason Hilling

Encryption is one of the best methods to protect security and privacy online.

It enables individuals to ensure their privacy when online when making mobile calls or using instant messaging and it enables their personal information to be stored securely.

Encryption enables people to exchange data confidentially and even authenticate who or what we are exchanging data with.

Encryption has helped users ‘trust’ the connected world, as it has infiltrated many aspects of peoples’ everyday lives.

The problem is that encryption is not a solution to all security challenges as it is used in a lot of ransomware.

Some forms of encryption technology, like the type used in the latest version of Transport Layer Security (TLS 1.3), can make identifying and blocking some threats more difficult.

Many network-based threat and fraud detection solutions have historically relied upon transparent, passive decryption of encrypted sessions via access to the server private key(s).

With the introduction of TLS 1.3, this is not as simple, as all the additional information needed to decrypt a session cannot be sniffed from the line.

TLS 1.3 dictates that Perfect Forward Secrecy (PFS) must be used, enhancing the confidentiality of communications but forcing a rethinking of the mechanisms for dealing with another set of problems.

One area which does need to be reconsidered is the mechanism for detecting and mitigating some forms of DDoS attack.

The latest Netscout Worldwide Infrastructure Security Report (WISR) confirms attacks targeting encrypted web services have become increasingly common in recent years.

Specifically, in 2017, 53% of enterprise, government and education (EGE) organisations detected attacks on encrypted services at the application layer. 

Application layer attacks use traffic that is very difficult to distinguish from genuine user traffic, often requiring analysis of the actual application layer transaction to identify the patterns of activity involved in an attack. 

The approach to this process must change as TLS 1.3 is adopted.

The sharing of keys

One approach is to use a Content Delivery Network (CDN) service, as these types of service can be effective against application layer attacks.

Where encrypted services are being protected, this can mean the service owner handing over or generating private keys for use by the third-party provider.

Whether this occurs or not, the CDN provider will terminate and decrypt customer communication within their environment for inspection.

This can allow them to mitigate application-layer DDoS attacks, but there are other risks around confidentiality. Sometimes these risks are acceptable to end-customers and service owners, and sometimes not, leading to the second option of using an on-network reverse-proxy to do the job.

Using an organisation’s own reverse-proxies is common for load-balancing, as they inherently allow traffic to be inspected.

In an ideal world, the proxy would provide telemetry to a DDoS protection solution so that attacking hosts could be identified and blocked, preventing resources being consumed on the proxy, as proxies are susceptible to state-exhaustion DDoS attacks.

State-exhaustion attacks target the ability of the proxy to manage sessions and are very common. 

This problem can be overcome by front-ending the reverse proxy with a DDoS protection solution that can identify and block both state-exhaustion attacks and those that target TLS negotiation.

However, there is a third option: transparent, passive decryption.

Passive decryption is still possible with TLS 1.3 when using ephemeral Diffie-Helman ciphers (as used in TLS 1.3), but only if static keys are re-used across sessions, shared with on-network security solutions (using a key management platform) and then periodically cycled. 

This mechanism allows transparent decryption of traffic, for threat identification and blocking, in a similar manner to existing pre-TLS 1.3 mechanisms.

As with all things in security, different solutions will appeal to different organisations based on their needs, those of their customers and prevailing regulatory requirements. 

However, with application layer DDoS attacks becoming ever more prevalent, an appropriate solution must be put in place.

Encryption is essential and PFS undoubtedly improves the overall security of the interactions with the connected world, but overcoming its impact is essential to other elements of the defensive stack.

This requires organisations to work across the IT, network and security teams within their organisations, to ensure they adopt the most appropriate approach for their business.

Story image
The current state of ransomware — and its future
Discoveries made by analysts at Sophos have unearthed a new development: ransomware code appears to have been shared across ‘families’, and some of the ransomware groups seemed to work in collaboration more than in competition with one another. More
Story image
IronNet expands Asia Pacific presence with new strategic partnership
“The combination of M.Tech’s extensive network in Asia Pacific and our unparalleled expertise in threat intelligence and detection will help more enterprises across the region to proactively identify and take down known and unknown threats before they happen.”More
Story image
Cybersecurity strategies must involve every part of the organisation - study
In the past year, a third of the breaches incorporated social engineering techniques and the cost of a breach caused by a human error averaged to $3.33 million. More
Story image
A brief history of cyber-threats — from 2000 to 2020
Many significant cybersecurity events have occurred since the year 2000 — not every one of them ‘firsts’, but all of them correlating with a change in security behaviour or protection.More
Story image
Check Point exposes Android malware vendor using dark net to rebrand products
Check Point security researchers have exposed an Android malware vendor using a marketer on the dark net to rebrand its products, with the intention of supercharging business and throwing off security vendors. More
Story image
Huawei: Corporates must focus on data minimisation and business continuity to mitigate data security challenges
"From a long-term sustainable point of view, organisations will need to adopt data minimisation and privacy by design and default."More