SecurityBrief New Zealand logo
New Zealand's leading source of cybersecurity and cyber-attack news
Story image

DIA accused of being soft on vendor who delivered faulty software

Intelligence systems meant to back up investigations into identity fraud, money laundering and other threats became so degraded at the Department of Internal Affairs that most staff avoided using them.

But attempts to fix the systems came unstuck to the point data integrity was at risk.

This is revealed in documents newly released under the OIA.

One part of the attempt to create an overarching intelligence system between 2013 and 2020 eventually worked, but another part was abandoned - not least because the department did not spell out what it needed.

The documents also show officials managed to claw back $351,000 in a settlement with an unnamed company that failed to deliver the full system.

The case of the $2 million system is another in a long history of IT upgrade woes for government agencies, many of them far more costly, stretching from the $100m failed Incis police computer system] to education's massive Novopay headache.

'Poor tools'

An internal DIA review in 2019 says that, in 2013, the department's units had "poor intelligence tools".

These units investigate and regulate identify fraud, anti-money laundering and countering financing of terrorism, gambling, and community and charity organisations.

"The department's intelligence systems were no longer fit for purpose, and most teams were not using the systems due to integrity and usability concerns," it said.

The DIA lacked any case management tool for investigations, which led to "a limited ability to trust reported data".

Instead, teams were getting by with manual procedures and using spreadsheets.

An aborted start was made on an upgrade, then delayed, then restarted in 2016.

But two years later, in 2018, the project that was meant to deliver a "robust and efficient investigation process" was in such a state it was judged too high a risk to deploy it.

Reviews show fundamental flaws.

"The vendor did not understand the requirements fully, meaning the solution was never going to meet DIA's needs," one said.

"This should have been picked up during multiple stages."

A review found the department was too soft on the vendor.

"When the vendors go wrong, DIA has tendency to fill in the gaps for them," a review said.

"DIA needs to be able to make decisions to stop paying earlier and push back more when deliverables aren't being met."

Part of the outlay was to buy licences to use the system, before it was even shown to work - and it did not work. DIA got back $116,000 of those licence costs.

Defects popped up again and again, from early on.

"The high frequency of issues being discovered means that testing has been in constant cycles of retest", a report in March 2017 said.

This forced compromises so the system was hard to use - and worse, data integrity "may not be as expected", the report warned.

This carried on into late-2018.

Data integrity was at risk from a glitch that was duplicating cases, and a failure to automatically provide a report on errors.

There also were typos in the software code.

"Attachments to entities... were not working.

"Compulsory fields... not validating."

The department pushed the vendor company to provide evidence of testing but "there was a general pushback that issues will be fixed as they arise rather than making sure it is right the first time".

The system "could not be rebuilt from scratch", DIA was told.

Its own oversight had been lacking, and its legal advice was not good enough.

"Risk escalation to the board was too slow and the information provided did not give the board a full enough picture to make effective decisions quickly," a review in February 2019 said.

"There was a lack of ability to remedy issues via the contract as it lacked robustness.

"Better legal advice at contract creation and during the ongoing issues should have been supplied."

DIA had assumed the main vendor had a partnership with another supplier; instead this "was later revealed to be a sub-contract type relationship which started to break down during testing and implementation".

Meanwhile, pressure was piling on to specialist staff whose "time commitments were heavily impacted by the project".

The investigation case management system - which had been so vital as a single place to store case information "in an evidentially sound manner", and to improve reporting and oversight - was written off by the board in early 2019.

The project's budget had been exhausted.

There was on consolation with the intelligence part of the system working. Two of the four key benefits expected in 2016 were met, one was partly met, and one - automated and standardised processes - was not met.

The new system should safely record, capture, analyse, search for and share intelligence information, the reviews showed.

But managers are back to relying on spreadsheets, in part, for security and auditing, and staff are still having to input a lot of data themselves.

RNZ logo
This story was originally published on and is republished with permission.
Related stories
Top stories
Story image
ABI Research
75% of 5G networks to advance to 5G-Advanced by 2030
5G-advanced is set to launch in 2025, and 75% of 5G networks will upgrade by 2030, according to ABI Research. 
Story image
Online bullying, harassment skyrockets since COVID outbreak
Harmful content reports have risen by over 25% since the outbreak of the COVID pandemic, according to Netsafe.
Story image
Examining the future of ransomware threats with Vectra’s CTO
As customers' valuable data move to the cloud, so will ransomware. What is the current landscape and what do we need to know?
Story image
Security Information and Event Management (SIEM)
LogRhythm updates SIEM Platform with latest innovations
LogRhythm has announced the launch of version 7.9 of the LogRhythm SIEM Platform and updates to LogRhythm NDR and LogRhythm UEBA.
Story image
HP Inc
Firmware attacks significant threat in age of hybrid work
Changing workforce dynamics are creating new challenges for IT teams around firmware security, according to new research.
Story image
FIDO Alliance releases guidelines for optimising UX with FIDO Security Keys
The new guidelines aim to accelerate multi-factor authentication deployment and adoption with FIDO security keys.
Story image
New study reveals 51% of employees using unauthorised apps
The research shows that 92% of employees and managers in large enterprises want full control over applications, but they don't have it.
Story image
Stock security features inadequate in face of rising risk
"Organisations must proactively find ways of identifying unseen vulnerabilities and should take a diligent, holistic approach to cybersecurity."
Story image
Security driving customer identity & access management adoption
"CIAM allows businesses to embed a secure identity layer into their consumer and SaaS applications, facilitating secure, seamless end user experiences."
Story image
SentinelOne integrates with Torq to empower security teams
"With Torq, security teams can extend the power of SentinelOne to systems across the organisation to benefit from a proactive security posture.”
Story image
Email threats spike 101%, remains a top attack vector
"Each year we see innovation in the threat landscape, but each year email remains a major threat to organisations."
Story image
Vulnerable APIs costing businesses billions every year
Large companies are particularly vulnerable to the security risks associated with exposed or unprotected APIs as they accelerate digital transformation.  
Story image
How organisations can mitigate IoT and IIoT security risks
IoT and IIoT come with inherent risks because they are often deployed faster than they can be secured, putting organisations in danger of cyber threats. Here are tips on how to mitigate those risks.
Story image
Businesses unprepared to defend against ransomware attacks
Ransomware attacks continue to impact organisations worldwide with high costs, but businesses are still largely unprepared.
Story image
Digital Transformation
What CISOs think about cyber security, visibility and cloud
Seeking to uncover the minds of CISOs and CIOs across Asia Pacific, my company recently asked Frost & Sullivan to take a snapshot of cloud adoption behaviour in the region.
Story image
Tech job moves
Tech job moves - Bitdefender, Cohesity, Fortinet & MODIFI
We round up all job appointments from June 27-30, 2022, in one place to keep you updated with the latest from across the tech industries.
Story image
Artificial Intelligence
Eight top DevSecOps trends to support IT innovation in 2022
The use of DevSecOps practices is growing, as it is increasingly seen as the best way to produce high-quality and secure code. So what are the current trends?
Story image
Without trust, your security team is dead in the water
The rise of cyberattacks has increased the need for sound security that works across any type of business, but with any change, buy-in is essential. Airwallex explains why.
Story image
Unknown connections: How safe is public WiFi in Aotearoa?
If it's not your own household WiFi, then who has control of your data and is your connection actually safe?
Story image
Artificial Intelligence
Juniper study reveals top AI trends in APAC region
Juniper's research shows an increase in enterprise artificial intelligence adoption over the last 12 months is yielding tangible benefits to organisations.
Story image
Jamf introduces new content filtering solution for education providers
Jamf has announced the launch of Jamf Safe Internet, a new offering that looks to deliver a safe online experience to students while offering better management options for admins.
Story image
Gartner's top recommendations for security leaders
"Leaders now recognise that major disruption is only one crisis away. We can’t control it, but we can evolve our thinking, philosophy, program and architecture.”
Story image
Zscaler launches co-located data centres in Canberra and Auckland
The investment will offer public and private sector enterprises greater resilience in support of their zero trust cybersecurity posture.
Story image
Digital innovation could shape the future of NZ - Microsoft
With cloud technologies available to more people around the world than ever before, it is not only businesses who will benefit from using them.
Story image
Web Development
Whitecliffe fosters careers for the future of tech
Do you want a career in Information Technology, Networking, Web Development, Software Development, or are you looking to upskill?
Story image
Cyber Criminal
Identity and access: the fight is on
Blue team defenders are used to protecting our data, applications, and users with access controls and other security mechanisms, which is why attacks like this are especially challenging when they target identity and access control systems.
Story image
Cloud Security
Palo Alto Networks bolsters cloud native security offerings
Latest Prisma Cloud platform updates help organisations continuously monitor and secure web applications with maximum flexibility.
Story image
Progress launches latest version of network visibility solution
In Flowmon 12 network solution, Progress has expanded its support for public cloud provider flow log monitoring and launched new features.
Story image
Document Management
NZ's FileInvite raises $10M in latest investment round
FileInvite has raised $10 million in Series A investment to fast-forward the extinction of email for requesting and collecting documents online.
Story image
Trend Micro
5G network projects driven by improving security and privacy
Trend Micro's new study reveals the prospect of improved security and privacy capabilities are the main motivations behind private 5G wireless network projects.
Story image
WatchGuard Technologies
Ransomware volume doubled 2021 total by end of Q1 2022
Ransomware detections in the first quarter of this year doubled the total volume reported for 2021, according to a new report. 
Story image
Datacom announces revenue of $1.45 billion, fall in profit
Growing market pressures and border closures saw Datacom place increased focus on talent development initiatives for both existing and future employees.
Story image
Delinea’s Joseph Carson recognised with OnCon Icon Award
Delinea chief security scientist and advisory CISO Joseph Carson has been recognised as a Top 50 Information Security Professional in the 2022 OnCon Icon Awards.
Story image
Oracle Cloud
Commvault, Oracle to deliver Metallic Data Management as a Service
"We are excited to partner with Commvault and enable our customers to restore and recover their most mission-critical cloud data."
Story image
Internet of Things
ManageEngine wins big in IDC MarketScape assessment
ManageEngine's Endpoint Central service has been recognised as a leader by IDC MarketScape in several categories including Internet of Things device deployments and UEM software for SMEs.
Story image
Video: 10 Minute IT Jams - An update from CrowdStrike
Scott Jarkoff joins us today to discuss current trends in the cyber threat landscape, and the reporting work CrowdStrike is doing to prevent further cyber harm.
Story image
Data Protection
How secure is accounting software data in Aotearoa?
A recent Xero study found ICT spending for NZ businesses has increased 25% compared to pre-pandemic levels, so how safe is accounting software?
Story image
Secureworks reveals new information on BRONZE STARLIGHT threat group
New research from Secureworks has uncovered new information on the Chinese threat group BRONZE STARLIGHT and how they are using targeted ransomware to initiate complicated attacks.
Story image
Video: 10 Minute IT Jams - An update from CyberArk
Olly Stimpson joins us today to discuss the importance of MSP programmes and how MSP partners are experiencing success with CyberArk.
Story image
Dark web
Cybercrime in Aotearoa: How does New Zealand law define it?
‘Cybercrime’ is a term we hear all the time, but what exactly is it, and how does New Zealand define it in legal terms?
Story image
Artificial Intelligence
Vectra AI named as AWS security competency partner
Threat detection and response company Vectra AI has announced that it has become an Amazon Web Services Security Competency Partner.
Story image
Blasé attitudes to cybersecurity by business a national risk
The largely unregulated state of cybersecurity in NZ, and consequential ambivalence of most businesses, risk hurting the country's trading prospects.
Story image
Zero trust security adoption rises 27% in just two years
A survey of WAN managers has revealed that multi-factor authentication and single sign-on are the top zero trust features implemented.
Story image
Tech and data’s role in the changing face of compliance
Accenture's study found that 93% of respondents agree or strongly agree new technologies such as AI and cloud make compliance easier.